How to Conduct a Board Self-Evaluation (Step-by-Step)

  • By: Josh Palmer
  • October 12, 2023
Board Evaluation
Reading Time: 4 minutes

Board self-evaluation is essential for organizations seeking to enhance their governance processes and improve overall performance. This introspective assessment allows the board of directors, trustees, and board chairs to reflect on their individual and collective contributions to the organization. 

Meeting software for board directors has changed how these evaluations are conducted, making the process more efficient and productive.

What is a Board Self-Evaluation?

A board self-evaluation, or board assessment, is a process where board members evaluate their performance, as well as the performance of the board as a whole. This process provides solid insights into how the board operates, its effectiveness, and areas needing improvement. 

Self-evaluation provides the following benefits in an organization:

  • Transparency: Enables board members to openly discuss their roles, responsibilities, and contributions, fostering a sense of accountability.
  • Continuous improvement: Helps boards identify areas where they excel and those requiring attention, leading to enhanced performance.
  • Alignment with strategy: Ensures the board’s activities meet the organization’s goals and mission. 
  • Stakeholder confidence: When stakeholders see the board is committed to self-improvement, it bolsters their confidence in the organization’s leadership.
  • Legal and ethical compliance: Regular board self-evaluations are required for legal and ethical compliance in some jurisdictions, reinforcing good governance practices.

Embracing board self-evaluations as part of governance ensures boards remain agile, responsive, and fully equipped to meet the ever-evolving challenges of the organizational landscape.

Free Tool

Navigate board software options wisely using our comprehensive vendor comparison tool

How Can Board Management Software Improve the Self-Evaluation Process?

Board management software streamlines the board self-evaluation process. The several ways it can enhance the efficiency and effectiveness of self-evaluations include:

  • Centralized data management: Board management software provides a secure, centralized platform to store all relevant documents, past evaluations, and meeting minutes. This grants board members quick access to historical data, making it easier to track progress and identify trends.
  • Automated surveys: Instead of manually distributing and collecting evaluation surveys, board management software automates the process. Members can complete surveys electronically, saving time and reducing administrative burdens.
  • Anonymity and confidentiality:  Some software platforms allow board members to submit their evaluations anonymously. This encourages honest feedback, fostering a culture of open communication.
  • Real-time reporting: Board software includes robust reporting features, enabling boards to generate and review evaluation results. This feature allows prompt action on areas requiring improvement.
  • Customization: Organizations can tailor board engagement surveys to their needs and goals using board management software. This flexibility ensures the evaluation process remains relevant to the organization’s objectives.
  • Collaboration: Collaborative features facilitate discussions among board members during the evaluation process, which leads to more insightful discussions and better decision-making.

Leveraging board management software can significantly enhance self-evaluation and improve director performance.

How to Conduct a Board Self-Evaluation

Board governance training shows the importance of regularly assessing a board’s performance and effectiveness to ensure it functions optimally. By following these steps for conducting a board evaluation, organizations foster continuous improvement, transparency, and alignment with strategic objectives within their governing bodies.

1. Preparation and Planning

Clearly define the purpose of the board self-evaluation. Ask yourself and your board members the purpose of the assessment. Is it to improve governance, match organizational goals, or enhance accountability? Establish specific objectives you aim to achieve through this process.

Choose an evaluation methodology that suits those needs. Common methods include surveys, interviews, facilitated discussions, or a combination of all the methods. Consider the size of your board, the resources available, and the desired depth of assessment when making this decision.

2. Data Collection

This phase involves designing surveys or questionnaires, distributing them, and collecting valuable input from board members.

  • Design surveys or questionnaires: Identify the key areas and topics you want to assess within the board self-evaluation. This may include governance processes, board dynamics, strategic alignment, and individual board member contributions.
  • Distribute surveys: Decide on the most effective distribution channels for your surveys. Board management software can simplify this process by allowing you to send surveys electronically via email or through a secure portal.
  • Collect input: Continuously monitor the progress of survey completion. Ensure all survey responses are treated with the utmost discretion and no individual’s feedback can be traced back to them.

By effectively designing, distributing, and collecting input through well-crafted surveys or questionnaires, you gather the data required for a detailed board self-evaluation. This data sets the foundation for analysis and discussions.

3. Data Analysis

At this stage, process and interpret the gathered data to derive meaningful insights. Verify all survey responses are complete, accurate, and without any inconsistencies. Summarize individual responses to calculate averages, percentages, or other relevant metrics for each question or section of the survey.

Then, group similar comments or responses into categories based on themes or topics. This format helps in identifying common issues or strengths. Synthesize the findings from quantitative and qualitative analyses to create a holistic narrative of the board’s strengths, weaknesses, and areas for improvement.

4. Facilitate Discussions 

After completing the data analysis, facilitate meaningful discussions among board members. These discussions provide a forum for reflection, peer evaluation, interpretation of findings, and collaborative planning for improvement.

Determine suitable dates and times for board members to participate in discussion sessions. Ensure sessions are scheduled well in advance to accommodate members’ availability. When discussing qualitative feedback, emphasize that anonymity is maintained to encourage open and candid conversations.

5. Action Planning and Implementation

Having conducted a thorough self-evaluation and facilitated constructive discussions, the board should translate the insights and recommendations into a strategic plan with tangible actions to improve governance and performance. 

Assign responsibilities for each action item to individual board members, committees, or external parties, if necessary. Clearly define roles and responsibilities, including who will lead, support, or oversee the implementation of each action.

Keep board members and relevant stakeholders informed of the progress of action plan implementation. Transparency and regular updates foster accountability and engagement.

OnBoard Improves Board Effectiveness

Assessments help ensure a board is adequately supporting its organization. While there are many methods for conducting these assessments, a board portal platform like OnBoard streamlines and simplifies the process. 

Among OnBoard’s many intuitive features is one for board assessments. It includes pre-built assessment templates and the ability to collect anonymous data. Once assessments are taken, data visualizations allow for focused analysis, leading to smarter, more informed strategic plans.

Other valuable features include:

  • Secure document storage: Ensures all board-related materials, including self-evaluation data, are stored in a protected and easily accessible manner.
  • Efficient survey distribution: Automation capabilities reduce administrative overhead and ensure surveys reach all board members promptly.
  • Real-time analytics: Empowers boards to make data-driven decisions based on self-evaluation outcomes.

Want to see what OnBoard can do for your organization? Download this free board meeting minutes template, which streamlines your meeting minutes and corporate governance processes, improving board effectiveness and efficiency.

Board Management Software

The comprehensive blueprint for selecting a results-driven board management vendor.

About The Author

Josh Palmer
Josh Palmer
Josh Palmer serves as OnBoard's Head of Content. An experienced content creator, his previous roles have spanned numerous industries including B2C and B2B home improvement, healthcare, and software-as-a-service (SaaS). An Indianapolis native and graduate of Indiana University, Palmer currently resides in Fishers, Ind.